This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.
In the state courts of the republic of singapore
[2026] SGDC 373
District Arrest Case No. 903890 of 2026 and others Magistrate’s Appeal No. MA-9262-2026-01
Public Prosecutor
Against
Ou Chunmei
GROUNDS OF DECISION
Criminal Law — Offences — Section 332 of the Penal Code 1871 (2020 Rev Ed) — Voluntarily causing hurt to a police officer and a paramedic in the execution of their duties
Criminal Procedure and Sentencing — Sentencing — Section 332 of the Penal Code 1871 (2020 Rev Ed) — Voluntarily causing hurt to a police officer and a paramedic in the execution of their duties
Criminal Procedure and Sentencing — Sentencing — Mentally disordered offenders — Adjustment disorder — Whether exceptional circumstances justified a non-custodial sentence for an offence under s 332 of the Penal Code 1871 (2020 Rev Ed)
This judgment is subject to final editorial corrections approved by the court and/or redaction pursuant to the publisher’s duty in compliance with the law, for publication in LawNet and/or the Singapore Law Reports.
Public Prosecutor v Ou Chunmei
[2026] SGDC 373
District Arrest Case No. 903890 of 2026 and others Magistrate’s Appeal No. MA-9262-2026-01 22 September 2026 and 13 November 2026
19 November 2026
District Judge Samuel Wee:
Introduction
1 While intoxicated, Ms Ou Chunmei (“Ms Ou”) lashed out at public servants attending to her on two separate occasions – on 20 September 2023 (involving police officers) and on 21 December 2024 (involving a Singapore Civil Defence Force (“SCDF”) paramedic). During the incident on 20 September 2023, she also hurled abuse at a passerby and at a police officer, and climbed onto the bonnet of a vehicle.
2 She pleaded guilty to four charges:
(a) One charge under s 14(2)(c) of the Liquor Control (Supply and Consumption) Act 2015 (2020 Rev Ed) (“LCA”) for conducting herself in such a manner as to cause annoyance to a passerby (“Passerby”) whilst drunk on 20 September 2023, by climbing onto the bonnet of a vehicle (“Sep 2023 LCA Charge”).
Foot Note 1
MAC-901618-2026 (C3).
(b) One charge under s 6(1)(a) punishable under s 6(3) of the Protection from Harassment Act 2014 (2020 Rev Ed) (“POHA”) for using abusive words to a police officer (“Police Officer 1”), in relation to the execution of his duty as a public servant on 20 September 2023, by shouting a vulgarity at him on three instances (“Sep 2023 POHA Charge”).
Foot Note 2
MAC-901619-2026 (C4).
(c) One charge under s 332 of the Penal Code 1871 (2020 Rev Ed) (“PC”) for voluntarily causing hurt to a police officer (“Police Officer 2”) in the execution of his duty as a public servant on 20 September 2023, by kicking his left thigh and stomach area (“Sep 2023 PC Charge”).
Foot Note 3
DAC-903890-2026 (C1).
(d) One charge under s 332 of the PC for voluntarily causing hurt to a SCDF paramedic (“SCDF Paramedic”) in the execution of her duty as a public servant on 21 December 2024, by kicking the right side of her jaw (“Dec 2024 PC Charge”).
Foot Note 4
DAC-903893-2026 (C2).
3 She also admitted and consented to five charges being taken into consideration for the purposes of sentencing:
(a) One charge under s 3(1)(a) punishable under s 3(2) of the POHA for using insulting words towards the Passerby on 20 September 2023, by uttering a vulgarity at her (“Sep 2023 TIC Charge 1”).
Foot Note 5
MAC-901617-2026 (C8).
(b) One charge under s 332 of the PC for voluntarily causing hurt to a police officer (“Police Officer 3”) in the execution of his duty as a public servant on 20 September 2023, by kicking his right upper thigh area (“Sep 2023 TIC Charge 2”).
Foot Note 6
DAC-903891-2026 (C5).
(c) One charge under s 332 of the PC for voluntarily causing hurt to a police officer (“Police Officer 4”) in the execution of her duty as a public servant on 20 September 2023, by kicking her throat (“Sep 2023 TIC Charge 3”).
Foot Note 7
DAC-903892-2026 (C6).
(d) One charge under s 14(2)(c) of the LCA for conducting herself in such a manner as to cause annoyance to the SCDF Paramedic while drunk on 21 December 2024, by shouting at the top of her voice (“Dec 2024 TIC Charge 1”).
Foot Note 8
MAC-901620-2026 (C9).
(e) One charge under s 353 of the PC for using criminal force on the SCDF Paramedic in the execution of her duty as a public servant on 21 December 2024, by pulling at her collar and refusing to let go (“Dec 2024 TIC Charge 2”).
Foot Note 9
DAC-903894-2026 (C7).
4 I sentenced Ms Ou to an aggregate of 9 weeks’ imprisonment and a fine of $1,000 (in default 4 days’ imprisonment). A tabular summary of the offences committed (in chronological order) and the individual and aggregate sentences (including the Prosecution’s and Ms Ou’s final positions on sentence) is set out in Annex A.
Background facts
5 On the evening of 20 September 2023, Ms Ou was out drinking with her friends – she consumed two to three pints of beer over dinner at a hawker centre, followed by another five to six pints of beer and some Martell at a pub.
Foot Note 10
SOF_[4].
Thereafter, the following material events transpired:
(a) The Passerby made a police report at around 10.38pm concerning Ms Ou being unconscious within the vicinity of the carpark of a Housing & Development Board estate (“HDB Estate”).
Foot Note 11
SOF_[3].
(b) At around 10.40pm, Ms Ou used insulting words towards the Passerby, by stating “tmade” (which is translated to “your mother” in English) – this was the subject of the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 1.
Foot Note 12
MAC-901617-2026 (C8).
(c) At around 10.45pm, while drunk, Ms Ou abruptly stood up and advanced towards an oncoming vehicle, causing it to stop, before climbing onto its bonnet (causing annoyance to the Passerby) – this was the subject of the Sep 2023 LCA Charge.
Foot Note 13
MAC-901618-2026 (C3); SOF_[6].
(d) After police officers arrived at the scene, Ms Ou lashed out at Police Officers 1 to 4 who were executing their duties.
(i) At around 11.00pm, Ms Ou refused the assistance of Police Officer 1, became verbally aggressive and shouted the abusive words “Chao Ni Ma Ma Cheebai” (which is translated to “fuck your mother’s vagina” in English) at Police Officer 1 on three instances – this was the subject of the Sep 2023 POHA Charge.
Foot Note 14
MAC-901619-2026 (C4); SOF_[9].
(ii) At around 11.01pm, Ms Ou kicked Police Officer 2’s left thigh and stomach area – this was the subject of the Sep 2023 PC Charge.
Foot Note 15
DAC-903890-2026 (C1); SOF_[13].
Police Officer 2 sought medical attention and was not deemed fit to continue his duties.
Foot Note 16
SOF_[13].
(iii) At around 11.05pm, Ms Ou kicked Police Officer 3’s right upper thigh area as he was attempting to place her in the police car – this was the subject of the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 2.
Foot Note 17
DAC-903891-2026 (C5).
(iv) At around 11.58pm, Ms Ou kicked Police Officer 4’s throat after being brought to Police Cantonment Complex – this was the subject of the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 3.
Foot Note 18
DAC-903892-2026 (C6).
6 On the evening of 20 December 2024 (around 15 months after the incident on 20 September 2023), Ms Ou was again out drinking – she consumed several glasses of beer and whisky at a bar near a hotel.
Foot Note 19
SOF_[16].
Thereafter, the following material events transpired:
(a) Ms Ou lost consciousness and suffered a laceration to the back of her head after falling from a bar stool, which she had attempted to stand on.
Foot Note 20
SOF_[16].
(b) At around 11.57pm on 20 December 2024, the SCDF Paramedic arrived at the scene to assist Ms Ou, who had regained consciousness, and attempted to place her on a stretcher.
Foot Note 21
SOF_[17].
(c) At around 12.18am on 21 December 2024, while drunk, Ms Ou shouted at the top of her voice (causing annoyance to the SCDF Paramedic) – this was the subject of the Dec 2024 TIC Charge 1.
Foot Note 22
MAC-901620-2026 (C9).
(d) At around 12.27am on 21 December 2024, Ms Ou kicked the SCDF Paramedic’s right jaw while the SCDF Paramedic was executing her duty as a public servant – this was the subject of the Dec 2024 PC Charge.
Foot Note 23
DAC-903893-2026 (C2); SOF_[18]-[19].
The SCDF Paramedic did not seek medical treatment.
Foot Note 24
SOF_[18].
(e) At around 12.41am on 21 December 2024, Ms Ou pulled the SCDF Paramedic’s collar and refused to let go while the SCDF Paramedic was executing her duty as a public servant – this was the subject of the Dec 2024 TIC Charge 2.
Foot Note 25
DAC-903894-2026 (C7).
7 Prior to the incidents on 20 September 2023 and 21 December 2024, Ms Ou had been convicted on 15 November 2016 of an offence under s 353 of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) for using criminal force to deter a public servant from discharging his duty, and was sentenced to a fine of $4,000 (“2016 Conviction”).
Foot Note 26
AOS_[4].
Parties’ positions
8 During the initial hearing on 20 September 2026, the parties sought the following sentences:
Charge
Prosecution’s Position on Sentence
Foot Note 27
AOS_[2].
Ms Ou’s Position on Sentence
Foot Note 28
MP_[4].
The Sep 2023 LCA Charge
$1,000 fine
The calling of a report (“IMH Report”) to be submitted by an appointed psychiatrist to ascertain Ms Ou’s suitability for a mandatory treatment order (“MTO”)
The Sep 2023 POHA Charge
1 week’s imprisonment
The Sep 2023 PC Charge
6 to 8 weeks’ imprisonment
The Dec 2024 PC Charge
7 to 9 weeks’ imprisonment
According to the Prosecution, the sentences sought accounted for the possibility that Ms Ou might suffer from Adjustment Disorder, based on a brief memo dated 17 July 2026 prepared by Ms Ou’s psychiatrist Dr Brian Loke (although the Prosecution highlighted that there was no clear evidence of such mental disorder or its causal link to the offences committed by Ms Ou).
Foot Note 29
AOS_[14].
9 The Prosecution did not object to the calling of the IMH Report. Under s 337(4) read with ss 337(1) and 337(2)(c) of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 (2020 Rev Ed), a MTO could not be ordered against Ms Ou as the Sep 2023 PC Charge and Dec 2024 PC Charge involved an offence under s 332 of the PC, which carried a maximum of 7 years’ imprisonment and was not a prescribed offence under the Criminal Procedure Code (Prescribed Offences for Mandatory Treatment Orders) Regulations 2018. Nevertheless, the Prosecution considered that the IMH Report would assist the Court in understanding the circumstances surrounding Ms Ou’s commission of the offences and the types of treatment she could potentially receive.
Foot Note 30
Notes of Evidence,13 November 2026.
10 The IMH Report contained the following material findings:
(a) Ms Ou suffered from Adjustment Disorder, which was a contributory factor to the offences she committed.
Foot Note 31
IMH Report_[11], [20(a)].
At the hearing on 13 November 2026, the Prosecution accepted that based on the IMH Report, the mental disorder had a contributory link to the offences.
(b) At the time of the offences, Ms Ou coped maladaptively by consuming alcohol to “self-medicate” and suffered blackout episodes from her alcohol consumption.
Foot Note 32
IMH Report_[20(a)].
However, there was no diagnosis of any alcohol-related disorder, and the IMH Report indicated that Ms Ou “denied drinking alcohol daily, denied having any urge to drink, denied experiencing withdrawal symptoms and denied losing the ability to stop once she had started the drinking”.
Foot Note 33
IMH Report_[10].
(c) Her mental disorder was treatable, and she had shown significant improvement with the treatment initiated by her private psychiatrist.
Foot Note 34
IMH Report_[20(b)].
The IMH Report also indicated that Ms Ou “stated that she had stopped drinking alcohol outside of her home since 2025 [and] stopped drinking completely … in March 2026 [as] she was fearful of the consequences [and] does not want to hurt her family or other people”.
Foot Note 35
IMH Report_[12].
11 During the hearing on 13 November 2026, the parties revised their positions on sentence to the following:
Charge
Prosecution’s Position on Sentence
Ms Ou’s Position on Sentence
The Sep 2023 LCA Charge
$1,000 fine
$1,000 fine
The Sep 2023 POHA Charge
1 week’s imprisonment
$2,000 fine
The Sep 2023 PC Charge
5 to 7 weeks’ imprisonment
A fine (with no specified amount provided)
The Dec 2024 PC Charge
6 to 8 weeks’ imprisonment
A fine (with no specified amount provided)
The Prosecution made only a modest downward adjustment because its original sentencing position had already accounted for the possibility that Ms Ou might suffer from Adjustment Disorder (with the IMH Report confirming the diagnosis and establishing the causal link with the offences); and Ms Ou revised her position after accepting that a MTO could not be ordered, but continued to seek a non-custodial sentence so that she could pursue treatment.
The Sep 2023 LCA Charge
12 An offence under s 14(2)(c) of the LCA carried a maximum fine of $1,000, a maximum of 6 months’ imprisonment, or both.
13 The maximum fine of $1,000 was appropriate for the Sep 2023 LCA Charge. The sentence accounted for the following:
(a) While drunk, Ms Ou advanced towards an oncoming vehicle, causing it to stop, before climbing onto its bonnet.
(b) There was the Dec 2024 TIC Charge 1 to account for, which also involved an offence under s 14(2)(c) of the LCA (see [3(d)] above).
(c) Ms Ou indicated her intention to plead guilty at Stage 1 of the Sentencing Advisory Panel’s Guidelines on Reduction in Sentences for Guilty Pleas (“PG Guidelines”).
The Sep 2023 PC Charge and the Dec 2024 PC Charge
14 An offence under s 332 of the PC carried a maximum of 7 years’ imprisonment, and a fine or caning. Imprisonment was mandatory unless there were exceptional circumstances.
The sentencing approach
15 In Public Prosecutor v Yeo Ek Boon Jeffrey and another matter [2018] 3 SLR 1080 (“Jeffrey Yeo”), the High Court established a sentencing framework in respect of an offender under s 332 of the PC, which applied only to cases involving police officers and public servants who were performing duties akin to police duties:
Foot Note 36
Jeffrey Yeo_[52], [57]-[61].
(a) The following sentencing bands, which were determined based on the twin considerations of harm and culpability, applied:
Foot Note 37
Jeffrey Yeo_[59].
Category
Circumstances
Sentencing Band
1
Lesser harm and lower culpability
Fines or up to 1 year’s imprisonment
2
Greater harm and lower culpability
Or
Lesser harm and higher culpability
1 to 3 years’ imprisonment
3
Greater harm and higher culpability
3 to 7 years’ imprisonment
(b) Under Category 1:
(i) A custodial sentence of 2 to 9 months’ imprisonment would generally be imposed for cases involving hurt caused to police officers.
Foot Note 38
Jeffrey Yeo_[59].
(ii) Fines should be imposed only in very exceptional cases, where the offending act ranks the lowest in the harm-and-culpability spectrum.
Foot Note 39
Jeffrey Yeo_[59].
(c) A non-exhaustive list of factors relating to harm and culpability was as follows:
Foot Note 40
Jeffrey Yeo_[60].
(i) The degree of hurt caused and its consequences.
(ii) The use or attempted use of a weapon or other dangerous implement or means (eg. biting) and its capacity to do harm.
(iii) The age, lack of maturity or presence of mental disorder where it affects materially the responsibility of the offender.
(iv) The circumstances leading to the commission of the offence (eg. the offender’s motivations for causing hurt to the victim, whether the offence was planned or premeditated, whether it demonstrated contempt for police officers and their authority).
(v) The timing and location of the offence, in particular whether it was committed within the public’s view and hearing.
(vi) Whether the offence involved a sustained or repeated attack.
(vii) The number of offenders involved.
(viii) Whether the offender intended to inflict more serious hurt than what materialised.
(ix) Whether any steps were taken to avoid detection or prosecution.
(x) The offender’s criminal history and propensity.
(d) The sentencing bands were premised on the offender having pleaded guilty and having no relevant antecedents, and appropriate adjustments could be made where the offender claimed trial, made unwarranted allegations against the victim, or had a bad criminal record.
Foot Note 41
Jeffrey Yeo_[61].
16 The sentencing framework in Jeffrey Yeo was applicable to the Sep 2023 PC Charge, which involved Police Officer 2, but not to the Dec 2024 PC Charge, which involved the SCDF Paramedic. Nevertheless, I considered the non-exhaustive list of factors relating to harm and culpability in Jeffrey Yeo relevant in respect of the Dec 2024 PC Charge.
The Sep 2023 PC Charge
17 The relevant factors relating to harm and culpability in respect of the Sep 2023 PC Charge were as follows:
(a) Ms Ou kicked Police Officer 2’s left thigh and stomach area, following which Police Officer 2 sought medical attention and was not deemed fit to continue his duties (see [5(d)(ii)] above).
(b) Ms Ou suffered from Adjustment Disorder, which the Prosecution accepted had a contributory link to the offence (see [10(a)] above). In this regard, the General Division of the High Court in Public Prosecutor v Soo Cheow Wee and another appeal [2024] 3 SLR 972 determined that mental conditions which were proven and causally linked to the commission of an offence would typically reduce the offender's culpability and constitute a mitigating factor.
(c) Ms Ou was voluntarily intoxicated at the time, which was an aggravating consideration (Wong Hoi Len v Public Prosecutor [2009] 1 SLR(R) 115 (“Wong Hoi Len”) at [26] and [44]).
(d) The offence took place within the vicinity of the carpark of a HDB Estate, within the public’s view and hearing. In this regard, it was pertinent that members of the public were present shortly before the offence under the Sep 2023 PC Charge was committed at around 11.01pm – the Passerby had made the police report at around 10.38pm concerning Ms Ou being unconscious (see [5(a)] above), and Ms Ou had advanced towards an oncoming vehicle at around 10.45pm (see [5(c)] above).
(e) Ms Ou had an antecedent under the 2016 Conviction for using criminal force to deter a public servant from discharging his duty (see [7] above).
18 These factors placed the offence within Category 1 of the sentencing bands in Jeffrey Yeo, with an appropriate sentence of 4 weeks’ imprisonment. For completeness, this sentence accounted for the following:
(a) Ms Ou’s indication of her intention to plead guilty at Stage 1 of the PG Guidelines (given that the sentencing bands in Jeffrey Yeo were premised on the offender having pleaded guilty).
(b) An appropriate uplift to account for the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 3 (see [5(d)(iv)] above), with no uplift in respect of the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 2 as the one-transaction rule applied (see [27(b)] below).
19 Further, I did not agree with Ms Ou that there were exceptional circumstances warranting a fine instead of a custodial sentence.
(a) In Jeffrey Yeo, the High Court determined that fines should be imposed only in very exceptional cases, where the offending act ranks the lowest in the harm-and-culpability spectrum, and would generally be available only to young offenders or offenders with some mental disorder.
Foot Note 42
Jeffrey Yeo_[67].
The High Court provided two examples of such cases:
(i) A situation where a very young offender shoved a police officer in a one-off incident away from the public’s eyes and hearing and pleaded guilty early (“First Example”).
Foot Note 43
Jeffrey Yeo_[59].
(ii) The case of Public Prosecutor v Soon Nyet Chin [2014] SGDC 269 (“Soon Nyet Chin”), where a $10,000 fine was imposed on an offender who had a major depressive illness and alcohol use disorder (“Second Example”).
Foot Note 44
Jeffrey Yeo_[67].
(A) In Soon Nyet Chin, the offender, who was inside a police car and intoxicated at the time, kicked a police officer’s left shoulder, left side of his neck, and left ear. The police officer was diagnosed with a neck contusion and left ear laceration, and given 2 days’ medical leave.
Foot Note 45
Soon Nyet Chin_[5]-[6].
(B) The offender’s psychiatrist expressed the opinion that the offence “was not premeditated and it was a one-off atypical occurrence” and that “if the [offender] continued with her treatment, her risk of reoffending was negligible”.
Foot Note 46
Soon Nyet Chin_[10], [17].
(C) In sentencing the offender to a fine, the District Court took into account that the Prosecution “did not challenge the assessment made or the opinions expressed by the [offender’s] psychiatrist”, and “was not pressing for a custodial sentence and had no objections to a fine”.
Foot Note 47
Soon Nyet Chin_[11].
(b) Both examples were distinguishable from Ms Ou’s case.
(i) The First Example was distinguishable because:
(A) Ms Ou kicked Police Officer 2’s left thigh and stomach area, which was more egregious than shoving a police officer.
(B) Ms Ou’s offending occurred within the vicinity of the carpark of a HDB Estate, which was within the public’s view and hearing.
(C) Although Ms Ou was not a “very young offender”, it was unnecessary to decide whether her mental disorder placed her in an analogous position, since the other differences were sufficient to distinguish her case.
(ii) The Second Example was distinguishable because:
(A) Ms Ou’s conduct could not be regarded as a “one-off atypical occurrence” given her 2016 Conviction and the offence committed under the Dec 2024 PC Charge.
(B) The offender in Soon Nyet Chin suffered from both a major depressive illness and alcohol use disorder, whereas Ms Ou was not diagnosed with any alcohol-related disorder. In this regard, it was pertinent that the IMH Report indicated that Ms Ou “denied drinking alcohol daily, denied having any urge to drink, denied experiencing withdrawal symptoms and denied losing the ability to stop once she had started the drinking”.
Foot Note 48
IMH Report_[10].
(C) Further, the Prosecution “was not pressing for a custodial sentence and had no objections to a fine” in Soon Nyet Chin, whereas the Prosecution was seeking a custodial sentence in Ms Ou’s case.
(c) Consequently, while Ms Ou suffered from Adjustment Disorder, this did not, in my view, constitute an exceptional circumstance warranting the imposition of a fine instead of a custodial sentence, because the offending did not rank at the lowest in the harm-and-culpability spectrum.
(d) This outcome was consistent with that in Public Prosecutor v Khoo Wai Keong [2019] SGDC 55 (“Khoo Wai Keong”), where the District Court found that the offender’s mental disorders (persistent depressive disorder and alcohol use disorder) did not justify a non-custodial sentence for an offence under s 332 of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed), and imposed a sentence of 2 months’ imprisonment (with the High Court dismissing the offender’s appeal).
(i) In Khoo Wai Keong, the offender, who was at a taxi stand along the main road outside a nightclub and intoxicated at the time, kicked a police officer once over her abdomen. The police officer sought medical attention and was found to have no abdominal tenderness or obvious abdominal injuries.
Foot Note 49
Khoo Wai Keong_[16]-[17].
(ii) The offender, who was untraced, relied on medical reports stating that he had persistent depressive disorder and alcohol use disorder,
Foot Note 50
Khoo Wai Keong_[12].
and sought a non-custodial sentence.
Foot Note 51
Khoo Wai Keong_[11].
(iii) In concluding that no exceptional circumstances justified a non-custodial sentence, the District Court took into account the following:
(A) The offender’s “drinking alcohol excessively to cope with his chronic low mood and chronic low self-esteem was entirely voluntary” and that the offender continued to drink until he became drunk despite knowing that he would not be able to control his anger or aggression, which led to the District Court’s finding that the offender’s persistent depressive disorder “had no or very little causal link to the offences”.
Foot Note 52
Khoo Wai Keong_[25].
(B) The offender was the aggressor, and his attack on the police officer was completely unprovoked.
Foot Note 53
Khoo Wai Keong_[26].
(C) Unlike the case of Soon Nyet Chin, the Prosecution had sought a custodial sentence.
Foot Note 54
Khoo Wai Keong_[27].
(iv) Like Khoo Wai Keong, a non-custodial sentence was not appropriate for Ms Ou:
(A) Both cases involved kicks to police officers, offenders who were intoxicated, and offences that took place in areas that were within the public’s view and hearing.
(B) Unlike the offender in Khoo Wai Keong, Ms Ou had an antecedent under the 2016 Conviction.
(C) Although Ms Ou’s case differed from Khoo Wai Keongin that the Prosecution accepted that Ms Ou’s Adjustment Disorder had a contributory link to the offence, this did not, in itself, justify a non-custodial sentence. Rather, the mitigating effect of the Adjustment Disorder was adequately reflected in the lower sentence of 4 weeks’ imprisonment, as compared with the 2 months’ imprisonment imposed in Khoo Wai Keong.
The Dec 2024 PC Charge
20 As explained at [16] above, the sentencing framework in Jeffrey Yeo did not apply to the Dec 2024 PC Charge because it involved an SCDF paramedic rather than a police officer. Nevertheless, I considered the non-exhaustive list of factors relating to harm and culpability in Jeffrey Yeo relevant.
21 The relevant factors relating to harm and culpability in respect of the Dec 2024 PC Charge were as follows:
(a) Ms Ou kicked the SCDF Paramedic’s right jaw, which was a vulnerable region, although I was mindful that the SCDF Paramedic did not seek medical attention (see [6(d)] above).
(b) Ms Ou suffered from Adjustment Disorder, which the Prosecution accepted had a contributory link to the offence that lowered her culpability (see [10(a)] above).
(c) Ms Ou was voluntarily intoxicated at the time, which was an aggravating consideration (Wong Hoi Len at [26] and [44]).
(d) The offence took place outside a bar near a hotel, within the public’s view and hearing.
(e) Ms Ou had an antecedent under the 2016 Conviction for using criminal force to deter a public servant from discharging his duty (see [7] above). Moreover, Ms Ou committed the offence under the Dec 2024 PC Charge while under investigation for similar offences committed on 20 September 2023 (ie. the Sep 2023 PC Charge, the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 2 and the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 3).
Foot Note 55
AOS_[11].
22 Based on these factors, a sentence of 5 weeks’ imprisonment was appropriate:
(a) The starting point sentence had Ms Ou been convicted after a trial would have been 7 weeks’ imprisonment.
(b) The starting point sentence was reduced to 5 weeks’ imprisonment to account for Ms Ou’s indication of her intention to plead guilty at Stage 1 of the PG Guidelines, which entitled her to a reduction of 30%.
(c) For completeness, I did not apply an uplift in respect of the Dec 2024 TIC Charge 2 as the one-transaction rule applied.
23 Once again, I did not agree with Ms Ou that there were exceptional circumstances warranting a fine instead of a custodial sentence for the reasons set out at [19] above.
The Sep 2023 POHA Charge
24 An offence under s 6(1)(a) punishable under s 6(3) of the POHA carried a maximum fine of $5,000, a maximum of 12 months’ imprisonment, or both.
25 A sentence of 5 days’ imprisonment was appropriate for the Sep 2023 POHA Charge. The sentence accounted for the following:
(a) Ms Ou shouted the vulgarity at Police Officer 1 on three instances (see [5(d)(i)] above).
(b) Ms Ou suffered from Adjustment Disorder, which the Prosecution accepted had a contributory link to the offence that lowered her culpability (see [10(a)] above).
(c) Ms Ou was voluntarily intoxicated at the time, which was an aggravating consideration (Wong Hoi Len at [26] and [44]).
(d) There was the Sep 2023 TIC Charge 1 to account for, which involved Ms Ou’s use of insulting words towards the Passerby (see [5(b)] above).
(e) Ms Ou indicated her intention to plead guilty at Stage 1 of the PG Guidelines, and was entitled to a reduction of up to 30%.
Aggregate sentence
26 There were three main rules or principles to consider in this case when determining the appropriate aggregate sentence:
(a) The one-transaction rule, which served as a filter to sieve out sentences that ought not, as a general rule, to be ordered to run consecutively (Mohamed Shouffee bin Adam v Public Prosecutor [2014] 2 SLR 998 (“Shouffee”) at [27]).
(b) The general rule of consecutive sentences for unrelated offences, which provided for a multiple offender who had committed unrelated offences to be separately punished for each offence (Public Prosecutor v Raveen Balakrishnan [2018] 5 SLR 799 at [41]).
(c) The totality principle, which was applied at the end of the sentencing process, and involved the court performing a final check to assess whether the overall sentence was excessive (Shouffee at [58] and [81(h)]).
27 I ordered the sentences for the Sep 2023 PC Charge and the Dec 2024 PC Charge to run consecutively, and the sentence for the Sep 2023 POHA Charge to run concurrently. This yielded an aggregate of 9 weeks’ imprisonment and a fine of $1,000 (in default 4 days’ imprisonment), which was not crushing and was sufficient and proportionate to Ms Ou’s overall criminality. My decision accounted for the following:
(a) The general rule of consecutive sentences for unrelated offences applied to the Sep 2023 PC Charge and the Dec 2024 PC Charge as they were committed on different occasions and involved different victims.
Foot Note 56
AOS_[13].
(b) The one-transaction rule applied to the Sep 2023 POHA Charge and the Sep 2023 PC Charge. While the victims involved were different (Police Officer 1 in respect of the Sep 2023 POHA Charge and Police Officer 2 in respect of the Sep 2023 PC Charge), the offences were committed within a minute of each other (see [5(d)] above), and had the same legally protected interests (ie. the protection of the police officers who had been deployed). Assuming that I was wrong and the one-transaction rule did not apply, I would have in any event found that the sentence should have run concurrently in light of the totality principle.
Conclusion
28 Ms Ou was sentenced to an aggregate of 9 weeks’ imprisonment and a fine of $1,000 (in default 4 days’ imprisonment). She appealed against her sentence, and was granted a stay of execution and bail pending appeal.
Samuel Wee District Judge
Gurmesh Singh (Attorney-General’s Chambers) for the Public Prosecutor;
Rayner Gooi (Panzer Law Corporation) for the Accused.
Annex A – Summary of the Offences (in Chronological Order) and the Individual and Aggregate Sentences
S/N
Date / Time of Offence
Charge No.
Offence
Prosecution’s Final Position on Sentence
Defence’s Final Position on Sentence
Court’s Decision
1
20 Sep 2023, 10.40pm
MAC-901617-2026 (C8)
Section 3(1)(a) of the POHA
TIC Charge
2
20 Sep 2023, 10.45pm
MAC-901618-2026 (C3)
Section 14(2)(c) of the LCA
$1,000 fine
$1,000 fine
$1,000 fine (in default 4 days’ imprisonment)
3
20 Sep 2023, 11.00pm
MAC-901619-2026 (C4)
Section 6(1)(a) of the POHA
1 week’s imprisonment (concurrent)
$2,000 fine
5 days’ imprisonment (concurrent)
4
20 Sep 2023, 11.01pm
DAC-903890-2026 (C1)
Section 332 of the PC
5-7 weeks’ imprisonment (consecutive)
A fine (with no specified amount provided)
4 weeks’ imprisonment (consecutive)
5
20 Sep 2023, 11.05pm
DAC-903891-2026 (C5)
Section 332 of the PC
TIC Charge
6
20 Sep 2023, 11.58pm
DAC-903892-2026 (C6)
Section 332 of the PC
TIC Charge
7
21 Dec 2024, 12.18am
MAC-901620-2026 (C9)
Section 14(2)(c) of the LCA
TIC Charge
8
21 Dec 2024, 12.27am
DAC-903893-2026 (C2)
Section 332 of the PC
6-8 weeks’ imprisonment (consecutive)
A fine (with no specified amount provided)
5 weeks’ imprisonment (consecutive)
9
21 Dec 2024, 12.41am
DAC-903894-2026 (C7)
Section 353 of the PC
TIC Charge
Aggregate Sentence
10-12 weeks’ imprisonment (after a reduction on account of the totality principle) and $1,000 fine
Fines only
9 weeks’ imprisonment and $1,000 fine (in default 4 days’ imprisonment)
This judgment text has undergone conversion so that it is mobile and web-friendly. This may have created formatting or alignment issues. Please refer to the PDF copy for a print-friendly version.